David Cameron's call for a ban on
Dr. Yusuf Al Qaradawi, the most prominent Muslim scholar and Chair of the
International Union of Muslim Scholars, is gravely misguided and ill-informed. In a speech to a working group between the Conservatives and the main German
centre-right party the CDU, Mr Cameron urged the Government to "expel
or refuse entry to those who preach hate, pit one faith against another and
divide our society" and accused Dr. Qaradawi of "preaching hatred and sowing
division".
No doubt Mr Cameron's
ignorant statements on Dr. Qaradawi are the result of mis-briefing by his
neo-Conservative aides - foremost among them being Michael Gove. What is curious
is that Gove has been active in "preaching hatred and sowing division" himself.
A right-wing think tank of which he is a Patron, Policy Exchange, has been at
the forefront of efforts to promote the familiar neo-con agenda of stigmatising
Muslims and was only recently exposed as fabricating evidence in order to smear
the Muslim community and its places of worship.
Mr. Cameron's comments on
Qaradawi show a similar disregard for evidence. If he cared to look more
closely at Dr. Qaradawi's own writings and track record, he would see that
Qaradawi has been a prominent and staunch critic of terrorism,
condemning it as a "heinous crime" and an act of "total barbarism". He condemned the attacks of September 11 2001 as "a grave sin" and was a leading member of the panel of prominent Muslim
scholars which issued a fatwa deploring the attacks and stating that it was the
duty of all Muslims to attempt to bring the terrorists to justice.
Far
from preaching hatred, Dr. Qaradawi has himself severely denounced preachers
such as Abu Hamza and Abu Qatada, stating "there are among Muslims
some fringe groups who represent the strength of violence and extremism, such
as Abu Hamza and Abu Qatada, but these have no scholarly, practical or
community weight... We call for love not hate, for tolerance not fanaticism,
for peace not war."
Moreover,
Dr. Qaradawi has been an outspoken supporter of the full participation
of women in all spheres of public life and has been unswerving in arguing in
favour of female education and employment (indeed his commitment to this can be
seen in the fact that his daughter is one of the few prominent nuclear
physicists in the Muslim world).
Cameron's efforts to portray Dr
Qaradawi as an anti-semite are disproved by Dr. Qaradawi's constant emphasis on
the special relations Muslims have had with Jews down the centuries, notably
when the west persecuted and expelled them. Indeed,
his work to promote understanding between Islam and other faiths has led him to
share platforms and meet with such prominent figures as former-US President
Bill Clinton, the French Foreign Minister, the Italian Foreign Minister and the
Spanish royal family.
Mohammad
Sawalha, President of BMI, stated, "It is astounding that Mr. Cameron is
so perturbed by Dr. Qaradawi who has absolutely no involvement in violence
entering the UK
while apparently finding no difficulty in staunchly supporting the Israeli government's
policy of systematic oppression of the Palestinian people. Mr Cameron's
statement that "we must expel or refuse entry to
those who preach hate and divide our society" is laughable when considering the
vast number of his own MPs who have been forced to step down over the past year
due to their racist views. This latest statement, far from being grounded in
any real concern to combat prejudice and bigotry, is nothing more than a badly-disguised effort to distract from the more serious
problems Mr Cameron faces within his own party". |